Committing to just one fall footwear purchase can be a decision of Sophie’s Choice proportions. After all, picking between a pumpkin-spice latte and a caramel macchiato sometimes feels like a choice of epic proportions. This season feels particularly challenging thanks to the daunting plethora of options: From hiking boots-gone-fab to ankle booties continuing their reign to sneakers in every incarnation and color, the options are endless. But you’re in luck because we took it upon ourselves to do the heavy-lifting for you and rounded up 20 fail-proof pairs you’ll want to get your feet into ASAP. At under $200 a pop, they’re all a steal—so go ahead, buy a few pairs. We know you want to.